Old Homestead

The Old Homestead, a New York City institution, is one of the country’s oldest steakhouses and is known for serving the finest steaks in the Big Apple for nearly 150 years. With their second location in Atlantic City, guests can experience their trademarked domestically raised, hand-massaged Kobe beef on both sides of the river. Brothers and owners Marc and Greg Sherry believe in the adage “don’t mess with a good thing,” which is why the menu at their steakhouse in Atlantic City nearly mirrors the one in New York. And for good reason: "We haven't had an empty seat in quite a few years," Greg explained. Now visitors to Borgata have the chance to see why.

Want your next dinner reservation comped? Become a URComped VIP (it's free).

URComped is an independent review platform and is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by any of the casinos, slot machine manufacturers, or other entities mentioned on this site. The views and opinions expressed in the reviews are solely those of the individual contributors and do not reflect those of URComped or its staff.

All trademarks, logos, and brand names appearing on this website are the property of their respective owners. Use of these marks does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by their holders. Trademarks and names are used under nominative fair use for the purpose of identification and commentary only.

Content on URComped, including user-submitted reviews, photographs, and comments, is copyrighted by their respective authors. Reproduction, redistribution, or use of any part of this site in any form without express written permission is prohibited, except as allowed under fair use principles for purposes of commentary, criticism, and educational use.

URComped does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information on the site and expressly disclaims liability for errors or omissions in the information provided. Users are encouraged to verify critical information independently.

Reviews

Results shows recent 10 reviews

5 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

Our waiter, Michael, was awesome and his recommendations we're flawless. The crab and shrimp appetizer (request all crab) as well as the bacon were amazing. Great service, got us out just in time for our show.

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

Had dinner there Monday night 7/2, we were sat in a box room and asked for our table to be changed which we were moved to a much better table. Service was terrible, no one greeted us for quite some time. Customers around us were greeted and served before us and treated like high rollers. Felt like I was at a diner and not a up scale steak house. Thankfully the food was phenomenal but very disappointed over all.

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

I have eaten here more than 10 times and have never been dissapointed with the quality of the food or the service. I highly recommend the empire prime rib on the bone, although be aware that it’s big. The sides are also generous; a single prime rib with two or three sides can be shared between two people.

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

This place is out of this world. We'll worth the price. The chocolate cake is the best I've ever had.

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

Service 3/5 Ambience 3/5 Food 0/5 Bread/rolls AVG Clams casino AVG standard nothing special- came out in 5 mins Brussel Sprouts never had them like potato chips and burnt they were toasty portion was nice then replaced with the bitter Broccoli Rabe which was too bitter and just bland and small portion for $14 Filet Mignon Below BELOW AVG dry under seasoned no sauce Demi glaze was as thick was fudge pudding tasted like flour Gotham "House special" 34oz steak BELOW AVG under seasoned came with an onion ring, not juicy, not tender, just meat, quality so so Dessert was banana dream with 3 scoops of ice cream - due to the candle 1 scoop was completely melted by the time it reached out table, this dessert was below avg, not sure if vanilla ice cream was homemade This is nothing but a overpriced, overhyped casino steakhouse, nothing special about this, totally was not impressed, best party of dinner was the Titus Cabernet Wine. Only way they can get me back here is by COMP $$$$] . .. ... .... ..... Not a fun night here celebrating anniversary

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

Portions are getting smaller, service not as good as before. Food is still very good!

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

Delicious food and service. We only go for special occasions, because it is pricey. Everything is all cart, but the sides are big enough to share. Come hungry, you won't be disappointed. I recommend the filet mignon.

See this review

Comment

6 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

My husband and I went here a few nights ago. We were really expecting great things but unfortunately, that wasn't the case. The waiter left us some rolls. I took one bite and had to spit it out because it was full of nuts and I am allergic. Our salad and appetizer were fine but, I ordered a $45 New Your steak (and the steak was ALL YOU GOT for $45...no sides) and it had gristle running though it. Unfortunately, I couldn't even chew it. I had to leave a large portion of it on the plate. We also order the "garlic" mashed potatoes. I was unable to taste the garlic, or even the potatoes for that matter. They seemed to be completely unseasoned. Our bill was $270 and I think I would have enjoyed the buffet more. Also, the table next to us had about 8 men who LOUDLY used the "F" word every other sentence. Will never go here again.

See this review

Comment

6 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

My wife and I had dinner there last night. We were shocked at the poor quality of the meal. Our appetizer claims casino wasn't cooked. Claims were raw! We immediately sent that back our main course steaks were ordered medium and came out med well to well done. We both ate less then a third of our meals cashed out and left. We expected far more quality then a substandard Texas roadhouse type establishment. Needless to say we will not be dining here again and will be sure to tell our friends family and acquaintances

See this review

Comment

6 years ago

Old Homestead

Restaurant @ Borgata Hotel Casino and Spa

I got the Whale lobster and it was fabulous (4lbs at $30/lb). They shelled it for me and everything! I like steak but prefer seafood. The others in my party got steaks and said they were will worth the money. Very pricey but worth it. Staff was very attentive and nice. Recommend this restaurant for sure!

See this review