Reviews

Did not try their pizza but their sandwich was the worst I have eaten & I would have returned it& demanded my money back except I was hungry & already bowling.

Plutos has decent New York style kind of pizza . Not the greatest , not the worst . Prices are too high for the pizza though : and cup of soda was 4 bucks!! On top of the already ridiculous price for a soda they have the nerve to charge 1.64 for a refill for a 16oz fountain drink. So best bet would be to get a pizza to go and screw their over priced drinks

So the lady getting our drinks got them wrong told her what we ordered and she kinda argued with me. Rolled her eyes and shook her head the rest of time getting our drinks. Talked to the guy who brought our food he said he would tell his manager. But manager hasn't spoke to me. Got a salad and lettuce was brown and some of the cucumbers were dry. Pizza was not what I excepted. Very little sauce and way to much cheese I am not impressed. Four dollars for a drink and I can't get refills! Spent 72 dollars to feed 5 ppl. Was worst pizza I have ever eaten.

Don't get the deep dish! It was severely undercooked. The top layer of dough was gooey and gross. We tried taking the top layer off to eat around the undercooked parts, but both my partner and I got sick a few hours later with aches and bathroom issues ies. They were nice enough to cook another for us, but we had the same issue. It was as though they didn't precook it long enough and then when they warmed it up, it just wasn't cooked thoroughly. This is why cooks should eat their own food!