Reviews

If you expect a real Italian food, it’s not the right place! We have ordered risotto frutti di mare but it was irrelevant with rissotto. Under cooked and poor quality rice ! I told the chef and he gave the right but guess what! They’ve charged full! Bravo !

Very busy place. Waitstaff flying around. Took forever to get our meal and dessert. When it did come the streak was good. The dresser was half melted before being delivered. It was an ok experience. Probably won't come back.

Dinner was very disappointing. Very loud restaurant. The waiter tried to take our dinner order before offering drinks. Salads came 5 minutes after ordering. We then waited over an hour before dinner arrived. The waiter never offered a second cocktail. When we asked about the status of our meals we were told three times "it's on the way". The dinners finally came and the pasta was dried out. Possible overcooked or more likely sat under a heating lamp. We tried several times to get the bill with no success. The manager then came over to see how we enjoyed our meal. We told her how unhappy we were and she did adjust the bill without us asking which was good business on her part. We have visited Atlantis many times over the last 20 years and have found the food to be hit or miss at best. That applies to all their restaurants. SeaFire is too loud and the food inconsistent. The Bahamian Club's food is spotty at best. We never eat at Olives because the service and food is so poor. Now we will add Casa D'Angelo to the "don't eat at" list. Too bad for an otherwise nice resort.

Well decorated and presented but the food simply wasn't good. The waiters kept interrupting to keep filling up water and have small talk, it grew more and more annoying. We left within 10 minutes or less after getting our meal. As we were getting our bill the hostess came and asked how the meal was, I said it wasn't good and she just apologized and walked away. The staff didn't seem to know how to respond or know what to do. I strongly suggest going to Carmine's or Olives for similar food while staying at Atlantis. Our experience was very unpleasant.

The service here was outstanding. The staff were knowledgeable about vegetarian and eggless items. We did not order any entries but ordered several sides that were vegetarian. With the complimentary bruschetta, olives and cheese, we only needed 2 more sides to be full - got broccoli and polenta. The caramel ice cream was good and eggless.