Review for Five Star Tavern 55 Review For Five Star Tavern 55 Google User Feb 6 '16 at 16:56 Lost my first post so I'll keep it short. Runny burnt pizza, cold chicken parn, chewy tough burger, cheese steak with burnt onions, saved seats at the bar for people not there, overwhelmed staff who will asked you to move to a booth if your party is four or less and unfriendly bar service who save seats at the bar for people not there and seem angry for asking. Seemed convenient. Five times there with one take out as my friend likes the pizza. Six times disappointed. Never, never again. Oak Barrel Pub (formerly Gaffers) and Egan and Son have far better fare and treat you like are glad to see you and want you to come back. Overrated is too good a word for this ....award winning garbage. View full site to comment or like