Review for Presque Isle Downs & Casino Review For Presque Isle Downs & Casino Google User Jan 21 '17 at 3:37 Review is specifically for the seafood buffet. I anticipated coming for the seafood buffet for a full day after finding out I'd have the time to stop for it. I was highly disappointed. It's definitely not what I would expect from a $28 "seafood" buffet. There was No cocktail or tarter sauce for the shrimp in sight. No salmon no Mahi mahi. Just when I thought I had seen something that was going to change my mind about the buffet as a whole, the Garlic knots have absolutely no garlic flavor to them at all. Most food was cold and old. Italian pasta and crab cakes were good as well as the pizza. I was saddened to lear there was only 4 different choices of soda to chose from along with iced tea and milk. Absolutely hands down not worth the time or money. View full site to comment or like