Review for Five Star Tavern 56 Review For Five Star Tavern 56 Google User Jan 25 '17 at 16:55 YUMMY!!! The BEST thin crust, mouth watering pizza. If you love calamari, Star Tavern serves it up right. It's atmosphere is casual and friendly. Prepare to wait for a table on a Friday or Saturday night. But it is well worth the wait. View full site to comment or like