Review for Five Star Tavern 56 Review For Five Star Tavern 56 Google User Mar 17 '17 at 15:54 My boyfriend brought me there in 1976 and we are still going (got married along the way!). Pizza is great. Love the portabella/eggplant appy. Drinks are good and not watered down. Beers on tap (for the hubby). Some of the same staff from way, way back then. Staff is friendly. View full site to comment or like