Review for Five Star Tavern 55 Review For Five Star Tavern 55 Google User Apr 25 '17 at 16:58 I came here often in the 70's. Great pizza and calamari. Great service, pleasant and attentive. We left at 9:30pm and were accosted by folks hanging around outside the front door and in the parking lot. Really too bad because the food was GREAT!!! We will not be going back in the evening.. Really a shame... View full site to comment or like