Review for Five Star Tavern 54 Review For Five Star Tavern 54 Google User May 17 '17 at 22:53 Star Tavern is voted the "Best in NJ" for a reason. This is definitely some of the best pizza I've ever had. My boyfriend and I ordered the pizza of the month, South by Southwest: sausage, red peppers, red pepper flakes, onions & tomatillo drizzle. It was ah-mazing. And though their signature thin crust pizza was decked with this medley of toppings, it wasn't soggy. Incredible! Star Tavern is one of our new fave spot. View full site to comment or like