Review for Five Star Tavern 56 Review For Five Star Tavern 56 Google User May 31 '17 at 4:18 Best bar pie ever. While it's not fancy it is a masterpiece that has kept me coming back for twenty years. My kids love it and insist that it be their first and last meal every time they come home. Alright drink selection. Decent salads. Good wings and mussels. Great eggplant parm sub. Otherwise stay with the pies. My faves are the red spinach and eggplant and garlic. Pepperoni is tasty as is sausage. Go to New Haven for the white clam pie. But come home to Star. View full site to comment or like