Review for Five Star Tavern 56 Review For Five Star Tavern 56 Google User Jul 11 '17 at 18:50 The pizza is always the best in NJ...only 4 stars because the waitress wasn't pleasant at all. We seemed to bother her, especially when it was time to get the check and box to go...she had a 10 minute chat that she couldn't leave apparently. Thankfully, the gentleman waiter took care of us, even stopped us before leaving because we left the pizza to go at our table by accident. Very nice guy, he walked by and asked us how we were doing as well. View full site to comment or like