Review for Five Star Tavern 54 Review For Five Star Tavern 54 Google User Sep 10 '17 at 21:41 best pizza in town and we must visit every time we go back to NJ. They have great hours for the weekends, they close at 11 pm. That was perfect for us. We had a long day. We still made it before they close. The staff was great and bring the order while it is hot. The pizza is made to order. We have never went and not be happy with the service and the food. View full site to comment or like