We've only visited the casino and buffet at the Horseshoe. I'm sad to say that I cannot recommend either because I've been very disappointed with my visits so far. The casino floor always seems like a madhouse packed with people. The buffet ranks in my bottom five for general buffets and likely my #1 least favorite casino buffet I've ever visited (and that really pains me to say that). The selections were mediocre, at best, and there really wasn't that much variety to choose from. The "open all day" breakfast station wasn't even manned!
I give this three stars based on the name alone. Based on service and how I felt leaving the property... I'd be hard-pressed to give this 1.5 stars, at best... and I think that still has a lot to do with the name and not the service. The staff could care less if you're there or not (nothing like over at the Roadhouse next door). The food was terrible. The gaming floor is always a madhouse... I'll be back, but it's only because of the name and not the service. There are much better casinos to visit around town, and my suggestion is to check one of them out. Who knows though, the Horseshoe might just be your cup of tea.