Review for Treasure Island Resort & Casino Review For Five Star Tavern 55 Google User Dec 30 '17 at 15:59 We saw this place on a food show - rated as having the best pizza in NJ. Drove there from MD - and we were not impressed. My advice: don't order a pizza with lots of toppings. The crust came out very soggy. Stick to basic cheese or pepperoni. The pepperoni pizza held up and was nit soggy. However, I did not care for the sauce - a bit sweet for me. View full site to comment or like