Review for Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino Review For Seafire Steakhouse Google User Dec 19 '17 at 4:08 Made reservations months in advance for 8 and when we arrived, no table was ready but there were plenty of accommodated parties of 8 or more. Management was unapologetic when confronted about the discrepancy. Food was great. Service was mediocre. And when compared with the other “Fine Dining” options at the Atlantis resort, this definitely feels more like a Chili’s than a 5-Star resort’s premier restaurant. View full site to comment or like