Review for Five Star Tavern 52 Review For Five Star Tavern 52 Google User Jun 9 '18 at 2:59 So as a pizza lover, I had to taste “One of the best pizzas in NJ”. The pizza is definitely distinct, like no other I have tasted. The crust is perfectly cooked, great tasting cheese and sauce. Any hungry guy can finish most of the pie on his own, so if it’s a family setting, better order 2 to 3 pies. Reasonably priced, lively restaurant/tavern, but in a seedy part of Orange, NJ, so extra precaution around the area. I wouldn’t list it in my top 10 pizzerias, but it’s definitely worth the taste. View full site to comment or like