Review for Oyster Bay Casino Review For Oyster Bay Casino Google User Jul 26 '18 at 13:16 Exciting place to be! Had ice-cream from Messina before the show The Book of Mormon. I wasn't sure if I needed my parking ticket to be validated. Paid $30 after eating, show, etc. Like I haven't received spent enough. Awesome place to be and watch a show. Very nice staff! View full site to comment or like