Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

Seafire Steakhouse

The Seafire Steakhouse is a restaurant inside Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino in Nassau, Paradise Island.
If you've eaten here before why don't you tell us about it?

Want your next dinner reservation comped? Become a URComped VIP (it's free).

URComped is an independent review platform and is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by any of the casinos, slot machine manufacturers, or other entities mentioned on this site. The views and opinions expressed in the reviews are solely those of the individual contributors and do not reflect those of URComped or its staff.

All trademarks, logos, and brand names appearing on this website are the property of their respective owners. Use of these marks does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by their holders. Trademarks and names are used under nominative fair use for the purpose of identification and commentary only.

Content on URComped, including user-submitted reviews, photographs, and comments, is copyrighted by their respective authors. Reproduction, redistribution, or use of any part of this site in any form without express written permission is prohibited, except as allowed under fair use principles for purposes of commentary, criticism, and educational use.

URComped does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information on the site and expressly disclaims liability for errors or omissions in the information provided. Users are encouraged to verify critical information independently.

Reviews

Results shows recent 10 reviews

5 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

The service was awful! You can expect better service in McDonalds. The bus boy expected us to clear the table for him as we were rushed out by the waiter. Who asked us 3 times if we needed our food to go in the middle of dinner! Food was ok,not worth the money. would not recommend!

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

Very disappointing. Extremely over priced. $230 for 2 average steaks, 2 sides and 3 glasses of wine. Service was OK its nowhere near worthy of the fine dining price tag.

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

Everything was delicious. Service was great. Portions are huge. Worth the price.

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

The service was awful! You can expect better service in McDonalds. The bus boy expected us to pile all the dishes and the silverware. I’m sorry but I did not come to a steak house to clean by own table. The waiter was rude and rushed us out. Food was ok... would not recommend!

See this review

Comment

5 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

This place is definitely expensive... But I have to say, it's worth it. Aside from charging for water, the food was absolutely delicious and the service was excellent. I would definitely recommend going here at least once. And try the lobster Mac and cheese.

See this review

Comment

6 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

Very disappointed with my experience at sea fire steakhouse. For a place where you will be spending 50-70$ per steak, you should expect perfection. This was far from it. The steak was cold when it came out of the kitchen (almost as if they had reheated it) and the sides were pretty mediocre (the mashed potatoes were microwave quality). When we asked the waiter to heat up the steak, they simply took the same piece, put it on the grill, and made it well done (when I had asked for medium). Overall, the food was the same quality as a local steak house in the US, but charged quadruple the price. I would stay away.

See this review

Comment

6 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

Great food and service. We really enjoyed dining here.

See this review

Comment

6 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

Catch of the day was grilled grouper and it was pretty good. The better half had the tuna but that was under cooked and wasn't that good. Service was good. The highlights were the birthday singing by the staff. Nice place.

See this review

Comment

6 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

Made reservations months in advance for 8 and when we arrived, no table was ready but there were plenty of accommodated parties of 8 or more. Management was unapologetic when confronted about the discrepancy. Food was great. Service was mediocre. And when compared with the other “Fine Dining” options at the Atlantis resort, this definitely feels more like a Chili’s than a 5-Star resort’s premier restaurant.

See this review

Comment

6 years ago

Seafire Steakhouse

Restaurant @ Atlantis at Paradise Island Resort and Casino

Its best to have a reservation here because they are usually full. The food here is great. The staff are super. They really try to get customers to enjoy their visit. The price is relatively high but you do get what you pay for and more.

See this review