Reviews

It was just okay. A little underwhelming for me. I had a shake. May be better to try the cake or cookies next time.

Love this place! My fiance and I had seen the documentary about the owner of Milk and that made our experience a whole lot sweeter. We had an idea of what we were getting ourselves into going into it. That being said, yes it is a little pricy, but it is a novelty experience and a delicious one at that! The Cereal Milk ice cream tastes exactly as it's described - it is tasty, refreshing and nostolgic :) So glad we made the stop!

Very long wait but the treats are delicious. I think what makes the line go so slow is that people are sampling ice creams. The grouch in me just wanted to say to live a little and just go with it, but I understand people are skeptical about purchasing a pricey treat. I ordered the strawberry corn quake. It reminded me of a DQ blizzard in the way they make it. I believe it was strawberry ice cream with corn cookies. I would highly recommend paying the extra $3 to get the larger size for anything. It is literally double the size. I also tried the milk and cereal shake this one was not sweet, it honestly tastes like cornflakes and milk but it was surprisingly delicious and refreshing. Between the two I was surprised I liked the one that was less sweet (and if you track calories this shake wasn't very heavy on calories either, win win.)

Long line, but they worked fast. Compost cookie and Sgt serve crack pie ice cream were delicious. Located at the top of the spiral escalator on the 2nd floor.

First I'll just say, this place was so cute. Felt like a taste of NY on the strip. I tried the cereal soft serve and its definitely an acquired taste. Wasn't at all awful but it was very milky tasting and not very sweet. I got the cornflake topping and that was good. I also got the cornflake, chocolate chip and marshmallow cookie and that was good. I didn't think either of them were super expensive. The ice cream was 6.50$ for a perfect size and the cookie was 4$, which are prices I would expect on the strip. Not sure I would go out of my way to get them again but its definitely something to try!!

After watching the Netflix special, I was excited to try the cereal milk ice cream and "Crack Pie". The ice cream is okay, though not nearly as special as it sounds, and the pie tasted like others I've had before. It's a great example of amazing marketing overtaking the product, and the exorbitant price ($14 for both) highlights that it's pretty average. The entire pie was priced at $60+ and they charged $1.50 for a teaspoon of cornflakes on my ice cream. So been there, done the tourist thing, no need to repeat.

Way overpriced. The food was okay, but not for the price. The crack pie was good, but it tasted like anything you could make at home, definitely not worth the price. The cereal milk-based items were awful, the idea sounded nice, but in reality it doesn't taste good.

Overhyped and overpriced sweet treats. Not worth the money. They give a sample of the soft serve, and I actually walked away without buying any. I returned the next day to try a slice of the birthday cake, but it was $14. I bought three cake truffles for $7.30 (cake pops without the stick). They were good, but I couldn’t eat the third one because they were too sweet.

If you’re a fan of Milk Bar you’ll like this location. If you want more “normal” ice cream try Holsteins for milkshakes. The cereal milk ice cream with cornflake crunchies is everything... I dream of this stuff when I’m not near a location. (The cookies are also tasty, and if you’d like to get a bit buzzed, try a cereal milk White Russian. Yum!)

We got two milkshakes and a cookie. For what we paid, you would think they would be amazing. Well... it wasn't, at all. :( I've had many many better shakes at fast food places. Unfortunately can't give this place a good review.

Beautifully crafted desserts. They have interesting combinations of cookies, like one has potato chips in it. The blueberry cake truffle is awesome. So are the shakes.

We got the chocolate cake malt. It was an okay drink. It tasted like chocolate with chunks of like a cookie dough/chocolate chip chunks in it. The malt could've also have been more prominent. For 10$ I was expecting something special. I guess the price is just because the place is on the strip. The malt I make at home are much better than what they gave us.I would not go back.

We don't live near any of the other locations so bringing home a couple dozen of the individually wrapped cookies made great gifts to give people. One night we tried the soft serves, which were flavored as described. I'm not that big on dessert so the soft serve wasn't for me. I do enjoy the cookie varieties though and they travel well.